Dogs can eat a small amount of fully ripe tomato flesh as an occasional treat. Remove the stem and leaves, wash the fruit and cut it into manageable pieces. Unripe fruit and the green parts of the plant contain more glycoalkaloids and should not be fed. Prepared sauces require a separate ingredient check.
A ripe tomato will not poison a dog. A small piece now and then is fine.
The green parts of the plant can cause poisoning, depending on the amount and the dog. The stems and leaves count too, and so does any unripe fruit left hanging on the vine.
Those two lines answer the question. Neither fits into a single word. Say yes on its own and somebody feeds a bowl of green fruit. Say no on its own and somebody bins a safe snack.
So the search bar really holds three questions, not one: is the ripe red flesh safe, are the green parts and the plant safe, is processed tomato in a jar safe? The answers run yes, no and mostly no. Each one rests on different evidence. Each one leads somewhere different.
Read what comes next as a decision tree. What the dog ate decides what you do. Ripe fruit in a bowl means watch the portion. Green fruit or plant material means pick up the phone. A sauce, a ketchup or a tin means read the label before anything else.
Ripe fruit takes the softer verdict. The American Kennel Club says so in a line: "Ripe tomatoes are considered non-toxic to dogs and can be fed in moderation as an occasional snack." Press that same page on the green parts and it shifts. The toxins sit mostly there, the page adds.
PetMD folds both halves into one answer: "When fed in moderation, dogs can eat ripe tomatoes safely. Young, green tomatoes can be harmful to dogs."
Flip to the plant library at the ASPCA and the verdict turns. Tomato Plant, Lycopersicon species, is listed as toxic to dogs, cats and horses. The toxic principle reads solanine, and tucked into the same entry is a smaller note: "ripe fruit is non-toxic".
One plant, two verdicts. No contradiction sits between them. Treat the fruit and the plant as one object and you will get the answer wrong every time.
So the working version runs like this. Ripe fruit, small amount, fine. Green fruit, phone call. Anything in a jar or a bottle, read the ingredients first.
Dogs and tomatoes is two subjects wearing one name. The sources treat it that way.
Glycoalkaloids do the damage here, and two names matter. Tomatine is the one the fruit is known for, while alpha-tomatine is the main form in the plant and solanine is a close relative. It turns up right across the nightshade family, where potato and aubergine sit too.
Both compounds help the plant defend itself. Both collect in the parts people do not eat.
Pet Poison Helpline maps where they gather. The stems, the leaves, the vines, the flowers and the green fruit that has not ripened all carry them. The American Kennel Club says the same thing in shorter form: "Solanine and its cousin tomatine are toxins found mostly in the green parts of the tomato plant."
Ripening pulls those levels down. "As a tomato ripens and turns red, the levels of tomatine and solanine drop significantly." That line comes from Pet Poison Helpline. It is why a red fruit and a green fruit cannot share one verdict. The plant removes nothing; the levels simply fall as the fruit matures. The same plant is a different chemical proposition at each stage.
British guidance lands in the same place. Blue Cross, a UK animal welfare charity, puts it to owners this way: "Dogs can safely eat tomatoes, but they cannot eat the leaves, stems or young, green tomatoes." The reason it gives is the same toxin. Solanine can be poisonous when a large amount goes down.
NC State Extension keeps a plant record of its own. The Gardener Plant Toolbox calls Solanum lycopersicum a medium severity poison. Leaves and stems are the poison parts in that record. The berries it describes as edible, and berries here means the fruit. A toxicology note on the page, written with a poison centre toxicologist, adds something worth having. Since the database began in 1997, one child reacted to tomato leaves or stems, and the largest single ingestion logged was five or six leaves. That child had no ill effect.
Then there is the summer toxin list from VCA Animal Hospitals. The tomato plant sits on it, next to rhubarb leaves, onions and grapes. Its advice after an exposure is to seek veterinary care immediately. That listing is about a garden hazard, not a ruling on the fruit on your plate.
Two of those facts sit well together. The part, amount and dog's size affect risk. Human exposure records cannot establish that one tomato leaf is harmless to a dog. Ask a vet or poison service about suspected plant ingestion rather than assigning safety by leaf count.
Compare two poison lists and something odd shows up. One lists solanine on its own. The next lists tomatine and solanine together. The plant did not change between those pages. Only the labelling did.
The ASPCA plant library gives the toxic principle as solanine by itself. Pet Poison Helpline puts tomatine first and solanine second.
So does NC State Extension.
PetMD and the American Kennel Club follow the same order, and that habit matches the chemistry.
Alpha-tomatine is the compound this plant is known for. Solanine belongs more to the potato. Both sit in the glycoalkaloid family, but they are different compounds and should not be treated as interchangeable names.
The Merck Veterinary Manual muddies it further. Its entry covers Solanum species. The toxic principle it lists is glycoalkaloid solanine, in leaves, shoots and unripe berries. Tomato is not named anywhere in it. This is a genus level entry, written for a whole family and not for one garden fruit. Anyone who wants a ruling on the fruit has to look elsewhere: the specialist poison services and the veterinary media are where that ruling lives.
None of this changes your next move. The ripe fruit is not the hazard. Green fruit or plant material in a dog means the same call, whichever label is right. The naming difference does not establish a disagreement about ordinary ripe fruit, but distinct compounds should still be described accurately.
A small exposure usually lands in the stomach first: vomiting, diarrhoea, drooling, a lost appetite and lethargy. Pet Poison Helpline calls these the lighter signs. A modest amount of plant material can bring them on.
A bigger exposure reaches the nerves and the heart. Muscle weakness, tremors, a staggering walk and a change in heart rate come with the larger doses. Loss of coordination has a clinical name, ataxia, which owners usually describe as a drunk walk.
Every source lists the same set in its own order. The American Kennel Club includes loss of coordination, hypersalivation, dilated pupils, tremors or seizures, abdominal pain and cardiac effects such as arrhythmia. Chewy, whose page two practising vets reviewed, adds stomach pain and heart arrhythmias on top.
The clinical record runs wider still. The ASPCA takes in hypersalivation and inappetence through severe gastrointestinal upset, depression, weakness, dilated pupils and a slow heart rate. VCA boils the whole picture down to gastrointestinal irritation, incoordination and weakness.
Chemistry explains why the gut goes first. Glycoalkaloids bind to 3-beta-hydroxy sterols in cell membranes and break the membrane apart. They also block acetylcholinesterase, the enzyme that clears acetylcholine, in a reversible and competitive way. A leaking membrane and a lingering nerve signal together produce stomach signs and nerve signs at once.
The same picture exists in people. NC State Extension lists headaches, abdominal pain, dilated pupils, vomiting, diarrhoea, hypersalivation, severe gastrointestinal upset, circulatory and respiratory depression and loss of sensation after a large ingestion of leaves and stems. That list is about people. It still shows how far these compounds reach once the dose is large.
One figure is missing from all of this. No source read here gives a dog specific toxic dose for tomatine or solanine. Nothing publishes a milligram per kilogram threshold for dogs. Nothing says how many green tomatoes are too many for a dog of a given weight. The closest number comes from another species. The European Food Safety Authority saw no effect in rats fed alpha-tomatine at 20 milligrams per kilogram of body weight per day for 200 days. The same authority records that people can get acute gastrointestinal symptoms after a total glycoalkaloid intake of 1 milligram per kilogram of body weight. It also records that 3 to 6 milligrams of potato glycoalkaloids per kilogram has been treated as a possible lethal dose in humans. Rat numbers, human numbers and potato numbers β not one of them is a dog threshold. None can be turned into a safe or unsafe portion.
Size makes the first cut. A small breed or a puppy takes more risk from the same mouthful, because the dose lands on a smaller body. The American Kennel Club notes that a small amount can poison a small breed or a puppy. It also offers a sense of scale: the odds of a dog eating enough plant material to cause serious injury are incredibly slim. Pet Poison Helpline says lighter signs appear in smaller dogs after smaller exposures.
Age and size work together. A twelve-week-old puppy weighs a fraction of an adult, so a single slice is a much bigger relative dose. A poison service treats a puppy exposure as the more serious one. Pet Poison Helpline would rather you spoke to a vet before any new food goes to a puppy. Chewy takes a softer line and says a puppy can eat the fruit, with extra caution and a very small amount.
Health conditions change the answer again. Reflux, chronic enteritis or a sensitive stomach can flare on the natural acidity of the fruit. Acid irritates a gut that is already inflamed. A dog with kidney disease needs a vet opinion first, since the fruit carries potassium at 237 milligrams per 100 grams. Diabetes or excess weight brings a calorie and sugar budget into play. A dog on medication joins the same group, because any new food can unsettle a treatment plan.
None of those conditions turns the fruit into a poison. They make the portion an individual decision, and that call belongs to the vet who knows the dog. A healthy adult of medium size and a sensitive puppy do not receive the same instruction from the same page.
Dogs with access to a vegetable bed may chew plant material or find fallen fruit. Do not assume they will select ripe fruit and avoid green parts. Check barriers and clear dropped fruit and prunings so access does not depend on watching every visit to the garden.
Tomatine and solanine run higher in the unripe fruit than in the ripe one. Every source that covers the fruit puts green tomatoes at the dangerous end of the range. Blue Cross draws the line for owners there: leaves, stems and young green fruit are the parts a dog cannot have.
The unripe fruit turns up in the nutrition tables too. Take 100 grams of green tomato and you get about 23 kilocalories, 1.2 grams of protein, 5.1 grams of carbohydrate, 1.1 grams of fibre and 4 grams of sugar. Vitamin C sits at 23.4 milligrams. Potassium is 204 milligrams. Folate comes to 9 micrograms, vitamin A RAE to 32 micrograms and beta-carotene to 346 micrograms. Lycopene reads zero.
A ripe fruit holds the lycopene and a lighter glycoalkaloid load. A green one reverses both.
The question can dogs eat tomatoes splits hardest right here.
Garden access is one preventable route of exposure; the sources do not establish a proportion of cases. A fence or a raised bed takes the temptation away.
So the answer for green tomatoes is no. One small piece is unlikely to cause a serious reaction in a large dog, given how uncommon severe cases are. The right move after an unripe piece goes down is still a phone call, not a wait and see. Note the amount and the dog's size before you call.
Here is the one place in the whole subject where the professional sources split. The split deserves to be laid out, not tidied away. Most owners who ask can dogs have tomatoes in a processed form have a bottle in front of them. That is why it matters more here than anywhere else.
PetMD answers no for ketchup, tomato sauce and soup. The American Kennel Club is just as direct.
Chewy sits with both of them. The reason is the company those products keep. A pizza sauce or a pasta sauce usually carries garlic and onion, and both are toxic to dogs. Salt and sugar ride along with them. Ketchup can contain xylitol, which is toxic to dogs, and its salt and sugar load is high on purpose.
Pet Poison Helpline sees the plain versions differently. It rates plain tomato sauce and ketchup as acceptable in small amounts. Its reasoning runs like this: a plain sauce or ketchup is unlikely to hold garlic and onion in amounts high enough to matter. The same page still flags the high salt and sugar; the warning stays attached. That is why the two camps sit closer than they first look.
The rule for a jarred or bottled product is the label check. This is where can dogs eat tomatoes turns into a question about ingredients. Garlic, onion, xylitol or a long list of additives means no. Plain fruit and nothing else drops into the small amount territory. Even then it is a rare nibble, not a serving.
Start with what the tin, the jar and the drying rack share. Tinned tomatoes, paste and dried fruit all begin as ripe fruit, which is the safe part. Processing is what adds risk. Tinned ones are usually salted, paste is concentrated and salted, and dried ones are oil packed or salted as often as plain; drying concentrates the sugar and the potassium along with the flavour.
Processing can change concentration and add ingredients. Check the actual product instead of applying one sodium or potassium figure to every can, paste or dried tomato. Dogs on a restricted diet need a vet's approval; unconfirmed composition figures should not guide a medical feeding decision.
Tomato juice has its own gap. The authorities read for this page give no canine verdict on it, and canned juice is normally salted. The safe position is the plain one: fresh, ripe, unseasoned fruit beats anything in a tin, a jar or a bottle.
Cherry and grape varieties get a mixed reception in the source material. Great Pet Care lists cherry tomatoes among the human foods a dog can eat, with no conditions attached. The poison and nutrition sources all add conditions. Use ripe fruit only, with no green patches. Wash it, and cut it up.
Cutting is about choking. A whole one has the size and shape that can lodge in a small throat. The risk climbs as the dog gets smaller. Halving or quartering reduces the risk, but smaller dogs or dogs that gulp may need smaller pieces. No cutting pattern guarantees against choking. PetMD and Chewy both carry the choking hazard and the cutting instruction. Two practising vets reviewed the Chewy page.
One is fine as an occasional treat once it is ripe, clean and cut into pieces. Two or three pieces suit a medium dog. The weight based chart further down this page covers the rest. A whole one handed to a small dog is the version to avoid.
Everything here rests on one 100 gram reference. USDA FoodData Central lists the red, ripe, raw entry, year round average, as 94.52 grams of water and 18 kilocalories per 100 grams. Protein comes to 0.88 grams. Total fat is 0.2 grams. Carbohydrate is 3.89 grams by difference. Fibre lands at 1.2 grams. Total sugars land at 2.63 grams, split into glucose at 1.25 grams and fructose at 1.37 grams.
The vitamin list is modest but real. Vitamin C is 13.7 milligrams per 100 grams. Vitamin A as retinol activity equivalents is 42 micrograms. Beta-carotene is 449 micrograms. Alpha-carotene is 101 micrograms. Vitamin K is 7.9 micrograms, vitamin E is 0.54 milligrams and folate is 15 micrograms. Choline is 6.7 milligrams. Vitamin B6 is 0.08 milligrams.
Among the minerals, potassium is the one to note at 237 milligrams per 100 grams, against sodium at just 5 milligrams. Calcium is 10 milligrams, magnesium 11 milligrams and phosphorus 24 milligrams. Iron is 0.27 milligrams, zinc 0.17 milligrams, copper 0.059 milligrams and manganese 0.114 milligrams. Selenium reads zero. Phytosterols come to 7 milligrams. The fatty acids are tiny, at 0.028 grams saturated, 0.031 grams monounsaturated and 0.083 grams polyunsaturated. The flavonoids sit lower still, with naringenin, kaempferol, myricetin and quercetin all under 1 milligram per 100 grams.
Lycopene is the compound most people link to the fruit. The raw version carries 2,573 micrograms per 100 grams. Lutein and zeaxanthin add 123 micrograms. Cooking pushes the lycopene figure up instead of down. Plain cooked fruit has been listed at 3,041 micrograms of lycopene per 100 grams. Cooking also trims the vitamin C and the sugar a little, from 2.63 grams down to 2.49 grams. The fibre falls to 0.7 grams.
For scale, Chewy puts a slice at about 4 calories. A medium fruit sits near 123 grams and 22 kilocalories. That makes the fruit a light treat by volume, which is why it suits a dog on a diet. It also means the fruit adds almost nothing that a complete and balanced diet does not already supply.
The American Kennel Club lists fibre, antioxidants, vitamins and minerals among the fruit's contents, and names potassium, vitamin C, vitamin K and folate. PetMD adds vitamin A, lycopene and beta-carotene. No canine study read for this page shows that lycopene does anything in particular for a dog. Human research on tomato paste and lycopene absorption exists. The dog data does not. None of it becomes a health claim for a pet.
Preparation is a short list. Every item on it removes a risk you already know about.
Choose a fruit that is ripe, red and free of green patches. A fruit that is part red and part green is not ready for the bowl.
Off come the stems, the leaves, the vines and any green material. That step reduces avoidable exposure to the plant parts of concern.
Run the fruit under water before it is cut. Soil and pesticide residue sit on the surface, and a fruit grown at home carries both.
Cut it into bite size pieces, every time. A whole small tomato can pose a choking hazard. Cutting reduces that risk, and supervision remains important.
Plain is the only way it goes in the bowl. No salt, no pepper, no oil, no sauce, no spice. A dog has no need for any of them, and some cause harm by themselves.
Then there is the first piece. Feed one small piece and watch for a day. Diarrhoea, vomiting, itching, swelling or any change in breathing all mean stop. A reaction on a first taste is rare, but it does happen.
For a garden, the work sits on the other side of the fence. Keep the dog out of the vegetable patch. Clear fallen fruit and prunings off the ground. Put a barrier around the plants for the growing season. A dog that patrols a vegetable bed will find the green fruit long before it finds the ripe one.
Ask how much tomato a dog can have and no official number comes back. Pet Poison Helpline states the gap plainly: "There is no specific recommended amount, and portions should always be kept modest." The same page offers the common sense version: "A slice or a few cherry tomatoes is plenty for most dogs."
Owners who ask can dogs eat tomatoes usually want a number to sit beside the yes. The number that carries authority is a ceiling, not a serving. PetMD writes: "Treats, including tomatoes, should make up no more than 10% of your dog's daily calories." The World Small Animal Veterinary Association states the same ceiling as a global standard: "Treats should always make up less than 10% of a dog's calorie intake." The other 90% has to come from a complete and balanced diet. Tomato cannot live inside that 90%, because a dog has no requirement for it.
WSAVA also spells out what counts as a treat. Snacks, chews, supplements and the food used to hide a tablet all count. So does a pill wrapped in cheese. Everything lands against the same 10%. Too many treats unbalance the main diet and add weight the dog did not need. The safety guidance for tomatoes for dogs is a ceiling of that kind, not an allowance.
For owners who still want a number, Chewy publishes a weight based guide set at once a week. Extra small dogs from 2 to 10 pounds get half a cherry tomato or half a slice. Small dogs from 11 to 20 pounds get one cherry tomato or one slice. Medium dogs from 21 to 50 pounds get two cherry tomatoes or one and a half slices. Large dogs from 51 to 90 pounds get three cherry tomatoes or two slices. Extra large dogs above 91 pounds get four cherry tomatoes or two and a half slices. The chart is a United States source, so its weights come in pounds, not kilograms.
That chart belongs to Chewy and to a weekly rhythm. Read it as one source's frame, not as a rule. PetMD gives a different shape, a cube of ripe flesh about half an inch across. Do not extrapolate a precise serving from an unavailable table or assume a cherry tomato has one standard weight.
Nothing in the source material recommends feeding tomato daily. Every source that mentions frequency puts it at occasional. A weekly pattern is one possible routine, not a toxicology limit. The total treat-calorie allowance and tolerance still apply. Owners ask about frequency more than anything else. The answer repeats each time. There is no universal weekly frequency established by those descriptions; keep the portion modest and follow the individual diet plan.
A plain cooked tomato is not toxic by itself. Cooking creates no new poison either. The recipe is the worry. Tomato is rarely cooked alone. It goes into a sauce with onion and garlic, into a stew with stock cubes and salt, or onto a pizza base with both. Pet Poison Helpline points out that cooking by a recipe usually brings garlic, onion and salt along with it. Those are the harmful parts.
The cooked fruit shifts its numbers a little too. The plain cooked version has been listed at 18 kilocalories per 100 grams, with 218 milligrams of potassium and 11 milligrams of sodium. Its lycopene rises to 3,041 micrograms. None of that changes the verdict. Plain, cooked and unseasoned is acceptable. Cooked inside a dish with onion, garlic or a heavy hand of salt is not.
Yes. Tomato ingredients can be used in appropriately formulated commercial dog food, and Pet Poison Helpline supplies the reason. In a commercial formulation the fruit goes through processing that makes it safe, and it is also used in a controlled amount. Tomato pomace appears in some recipes as a fibre source. A dog eating a complete and balanced food with it included is not getting the green plant or a home cooked sauce.
The clearest example of the split sits right here. The same fruit moves from risky to routine depending on how it is handled. A ripe fruit in the bowl is a treat. The plant behind it is a hazard. A processed fraction in a kibble is an ingredient.
Allergy to the fruit is uncommon but real. The American Kennel Club lists hives, coughing, wheezing and difficulty breathing among the signs. PetMD tells owners to watch for itching, swelling and trouble breathing after a first taste.
Preventive Vet notes that fruit allergies in pets are rare. Hives, itching or a rash after a new fruit should mean dropping that fruit and calling a vet.
The useful distinction is intolerance against allergy. A stomach upset after a large portion points to quantity. Hives, facial swelling or breathing trouble point to an immune reaction. Breathing trouble is an emergency, not a case for watching. A suspected tomato reaction does not establish allergy to the whole nightshade family. Let the vet decide whether further exclusions or a supervised diagnostic diet are appropriate.
A chewed stem counts. So does a green tomato, a leaf, a vine or a flower. Any of them is a poisoning exposure, and the first move is a phone call, not a home remedy. Call a vet, an emergency clinic or a poison service. Have three facts ready: roughly how much the dog ate, which part of the plant it was, and how much the dog weighs. Dose, part and body size are what a poison service uses to judge the case.
Families search can dogs eat tomatoes, find a yes and a sensible portion, then meet the green fruit on the plant a week later. Those are not the same event. The second one is the one that needs a professional.
North American owners have two specialist lines. The ASPCA Animal Poison Control answers on (888) 426-4435. Pet Poison Helpline answers on (855) 764-7661, around the clock, and charges a consultation fee. Some veterinary hospitals still publish the older number (800) 213-6680. Owners outside North America should use a local vet or a national animal poison service. The published hotlines serve North America.
Do not make the dog vomit unless a vet or a poison service tells you to. The poison services are firm on that.
Go straight to an emergency clinic, without waiting, if the dog shows a staggering walk, tremors, a seizure, a change in heart rhythm, heavy or repeated vomiting, a swollen face or lips, or difficulty breathing. A small dog or a puppy that ate any part of the plant belongs in the same urgent group. Body size changes the arithmetic.
A daily slot is not on the table. Not one feeding guide read for this page puts tomato there. The occasional column is where they all land, and the 10% ceiling covers them like any other treat. A general suggestion of occasional feeding does not establish a mandatory once- or twice-weekly schedule. A dog on a prescription diet should put even that question to its own vet.
The ripe red flesh is not, and it makes a fine small snack now and then. Everything else on the plant is a different matter. Green fruit, leaves and vines hold tomatine and solanine at far higher levels. Ripe flesh is considered non-toxic in normal small feeding portions; tolerance and quantity still matter. A dog that chews the vine material does.
The sources disagree, so caution is the sensible default. Banfield Pet Hospital describes two toxins in the seeds, stems and leaves. Other authorities name the leaves, the stems and the unripe fruit only, and treat the seeds inside ripe flesh as harmless. Removing them costs nothing and settles the question either way.
They are different compounds in one family of glycoalkaloids. The fruit's signature compound is alpha-tomatine. Solanine is tied more closely to potato. Some poison lists print only solanine, which makes the two names look like rivals. Nothing about a ripe fruit changes between the two labels.
No. The leaves, the vines, the stems and the flowers carry the heaviest glycoalkaloid load in the whole plant. That is the reverse of the ripe fruit. A dog that has chewed or swallowed plant material needs a call to a vet or a poison service. The dog's weight and the amount eaten belong in that call.
No authority read for this page gives a firm figure. Some secondary sources suggest a window of a few hours up to a day. That is an estimate and not a measured latency. Watch the dog closely for the first day. Vomiting, drooling, weakness or unsteady walking are all a reason to call straight away.
A lick of ripe fruit is very unlikely to matter. Glycoalkaloid levels are much lower in ripe fruit; lower does not mean chemically absent. A lick carries almost no dose. Watch for any change over the next day, and keep plant material out of reach in case the interest grows.
A ripe cherry tomato is safe once it is washed and cut. A whole one is a choking risk, especially for a small dog, so halve or quarter it first. Treat it as an occasional snack inside the calorie ceiling, not as a bowl of food.
The first step after a suspected plant exposure is professional advice; the vet or poison service should determine whether home monitoring is appropriate. A dog that ate green fruit or plant material and shows no signs still deserves a call. The light signs can appear later. Keep food and water available unless a vet says otherwise. Write down the time of the exposure, so the timeline is clear to whoever answers the phone.
Do not hand over a home remedy, a fatty meal or a second treat to settle the stomach. The supporting care that helps in a real case, fluids and medication for nausea, belongs to a vet. The outlook is generally good when care starts early, and most dogs recover fully.
Tomatine poisoning is rare. Death from it is rarer still. That is worth knowing while you pick up the phone.
Escalate without waiting for things to get worse if the dog was small or young, if the amount eaten was large, or if the part eaten is uncertain. A vet may examine the dog, run blood work and record an ECG if the heart signs are present. Those steps separate a mild exposure from one that needs treatment.
This page is general information and not a substitute for professional veterinary advice. It does not diagnose or treat any individual dog. Any new food, and any suspected plant exposure, belongs with a vet who can see the dog. That matters most for puppies, senior dogs, small breeds and dogs with kidney disease, gut disease, diabetes or an ongoing medication.
Can dogs eat tomatoes? Yes, when the fruit is fully ripe, red, plain and cut into a small piece. When it is green, or part of the plant, the answer belongs to a vet, not to a food list.